Book Ad

If you enjoy Liberty Takes Effort posts and pages, please consider my recent books.

Brotherhood and Borders cover

Brotherhood and Borders

A thoughtful look at immigration, compassion, division, and the rule of law in America.

Buy on Amazon
Small-Town Boomers cover

Small-Town Boomers

A nostalgic look back at growing up in Randolph, Massachusetts, and the small-town Boomer experience.

Buy on Amazon

An Immigration Grand Bargain

The American people have once again chosen divided government. Beginning in January, President Donald Trump will face a Congress controlled by Democrats, raising the prospect of two years of political confrontation and legislative gridlock. The president's recent remarks about working with Democrats on immigration offer an opportunity to solve a decades-old problem and demonstrate that our government can still address important national priorities through bipartisan cooperation.

That demonstration may be more important than many Americans realize. We are approaching an age when artificial intelligence, automation, robotics, and new energy technologies will present extraordinary opportunities and challenges. Our aging infrastructure faces growing vulnerabilities, and foreign adversaries are developing increasingly sophisticated means of exploiting them. These are problems that will require sustained national attention, difficult choices, and policies that survive changes in political leadership. Yet our government has struggled for decades to resolve an immigration problem whose essential elements are well understood.

For much of our history, Congress has been the institution responsible for debating competing interests, negotiating compromises, and establishing the laws that govern the nation. Increasingly, however, Congress has surrendered much of that responsibility to the executive branch. Presidents govern through executive orders, administrative interpretations, and emergency authorities, while Congress struggles to produce durable legislation. Each new administration reverses policies established by its predecessor, and the underlying problems remain unresolved.

Immigration is perhaps the clearest example of this institutional failure.

For decades, Congress has failed to enact comprehensive immigration reform despite clear need and substantial public support for many of its essential elements. Polls consistently show support for border security, immigration law enforcement, and allowing long-term undocumented immigrants to remain under reasonable conditions. Yet politicians resist compromise for fear of alienating factions within their own parties. The most committed partisans often dominate the debate, while moderates and independents seeking practical solutions are left frustrated.

The result is an immigration system that fails the country, encourages unlawful entry, and leaves millions of people, many with established lives and families here, in legal uncertainty. We have lived with these consequences for decades, through administrations and congressional majorities controlled by both parties.

There is a path forward: a grand bargain that establishes common principles and a credible sequence for implementing them. President Trump should invite congressional leaders from both parties to negotiate such an agreement. Everyone involved, and the American people, must recognize that achieving their principal objectives will require meaningful concessions.

Rather than beginning with competing legislative proposals, leaders should first negotiate the essential elements of a grand bargain, put them in writing, make them public, and sign the agreement. Only then should Congress begin drafting the legislation necessary to implement it.

The agreement would rest upon three foundations.

Reforming the Legal Immigration System. Legal immigration should better advance America's economic, demographic, and humanitarian interests. Asylum, employment- and family-based immigration, diversity lotteries, temporary protected status, integration and assimilation, and other elements of existing law should be evaluated and revised where necessary. The objective should be a coherent system that serves the nation's interests while providing lawful and predictable opportunities for immigration.

Immigration Enforcement. America has the right and responsibility to secure its borders, determine who may enter and remain, and enforce its laws. State and local sanctuary policies that impede lawful enforcement must end. Enforcement should be disciplined and humane, with interior efforts focused on criminals, gang members, documented public-safety threats, and individuals subject to final, enforceable removal orders. A credible immigration system requires both secure borders and consistent enforcement of the law.

New Permanent Legal Status. Legislation would create a new permanent legal status for undocumented immigrants who have continuously resided in the United States since before January 1, 2021. Eligible individuals could remain indefinitely as long as they obey the law, but they could not change their immigration status, become citizens, or vote. Permanently barring citizenship would recognize the consequences of unlawful entry while giving long-settled immigrants and their families the security needed to build their lives in America.

Following enactment, eligible immigrants could register for temporary legal status and submit documentation establishing their identity, residence, tax compliance, criminal history, and other statutory qualifications. Those who satisfy the requirements would receive the new permanent legal status. The objective is to bring long-settled immigrants out of the shadows, permit them to live and work lawfully, and end the uncertainty their families face.

The sequence of implementation is essential. The Reagan-era reforms legalized millions, but inadequate enforcement allowed illegal immigration to continue, undermining public confidence in subsequent proposals. A new agreement must establish precise timelines, measurable checkpoints, and independent oversight so that neither party can achieve its principal objectives while abandoning commitments made to the other. Trust cannot depend upon promises alone.

None of this will be easy. Both parties will have to accept provisions they would prefer to reject, and both will face criticism from their most committed supporters. But that is the nature of representative government. Congress was not created merely to express the competing passions of the electorate. It was created to reconcile those interests through deliberation, compromise, and legislation.

The approaching congressional session will test whether our elected representatives are prepared to exercise that responsibility. Democrats will have opportunities to investigate the administration, challenge its policies, and advance their own priorities. Republicans will continue defending the president's agenda. Oversight and political disagreement are legitimate functions of government, but neither party should confuse perpetual confrontation with governing.

My concern extends well beyond immigration. I have recently written about the vulnerability of America's critical infrastructure to cyberattacks and technical failures. Our economy, financial institutions, communications networks, transportation systems, and national defense increasingly depend upon interconnected technologies. Artificial intelligence is providing extraordinary new capabilities, including tools that can exploit vulnerabilities in systems upon which we depend.

At the same time, AI, robotics, and automation may fundamentally alter employment, education, economic opportunity, and the relationship between work and personal fulfillment. The possibilities are enormous, but so are the responsibilities. Preparing for these changes will require national priorities that extend well beyond the next election.

If Congress cannot resolve an immigration problem that has been debated for decades, how can we expect it to address challenges of this magnitude?

The repeated political upheavals of recent years suggest that Americans are searching for leaders who can chart a different course. Yet changing the occupants of the White House or the balance of power in Congress has not resolved the underlying inability to govern effectively. The incentives of modern politics increasingly reward confrontation, fundraising, and electoral advantage rather than difficult, sustained legislative work.

Immigration reform offers an opportunity to begin changing that pattern. A successful grand bargain would do more than secure the border, reform legal immigration, and resolve the status of millions of long-settled residents. It would demonstrate that elected representatives can recognize legitimate competing interests, make difficult compromises, and establish durable policies that serve the nation.

We cannot expect every political disagreement to disappear, nor should we. Our constitutional system was designed to accommodate disagreement while providing a means of reaching decisions and governing the country.

America possesses extraordinary technological, economic, and intellectual resources. What concerns me is whether our political institutions retain the capacity to organize those resources effectively and prepare for the challenges ahead.

Immigration reform is an opportunity to demonstrate that we can still govern ourselves. If we cannot meet this challenge, we should be deeply concerned about our ability to meet the far greater ones approaching.

NOTE: I wrote a book, "Brotherhood and Borders: Immigration, Compassion, and the Rule of Law in America," that provides detailed information on this issue if you have further interest. It is available on Amazon through the link above. I have also visited Capital Hill to try and move this isssue forward.  If you see value in this idea, please, like it, share it, and forward your opinion to your congressional representatives.  If you don't nothing will change.

------

SHARING: Please consider sharing these blog posts via social media or via email if you find them interesting by providing a link to https://www.libertytakeseffort.com

DISTRIBUTION: If you would like to receive these blog posts in newsletter form to your email please send an email to libertytakeseffort@gmail.com. To see archived blog posts since 2014, visit www.libertytakeseffort.com

DISCLAIMER: The entire contents of this website are based solely upon the opinions and thoughts of the author unless otherwise noted. It is not considered advice for action by readers in any realm of human activity. Its purpose is to stimulate discussion on topics of interest to readers to further inform the public square. Use of any information in this site is at the sole choice and risk of the reader.


Coincidence?

Over the past few weeks, disruptions have affected several critical American systems, including FAA flight operations, banking services, Microsoft platforms, and—most troublingly—the National Security Agency's classified communications network, NSANet, which was reportedly impaired for nearly four days.

Officials have attributed these incidents to unrelated technical failures, maintenance issues, and software problems. Some journalists and members of Congress have questioned those explanations, but key questions remain: What failed? Why did recovery take so long? And what evidence supports the conclusion that the events were unrelated? Officials may be right, but their explanations still deserve serious scrutiny.

My skepticism is grounded in experience. As a U.S. Naval Intelligence Officer, I worked in classified environments that intersected with NSA operations extensively. Later, as the founder and CEO of a regional fiber-optic telecommunications company, I leased dedicated wavelengths of light to a federal agency for classified communications. The agency insisted on controlling the optical layer itself to prevent intermediaries from accessing its transmissions.

I was also a Microsoft Certified Network Engineer and served as Chief Information Officer for a public school system and a college. I designed and built networks and ensured essential services stayed operational.

Consider updating a school email server. We planned for possible failures by preserving system images and backups, establishing recovery procedures, and scheduling changes late at night, often with a technical specialist on hand. If an update failed, we needed to restore service quickly. Even a one-hour outage during the school day was unacceptable. That was a school email system. We are now told that software maintenance disrupted the NSA's classified communications network for days.

NSANet is far more complex, and classified systems pose unusual recovery challenges. But complexity makes testing, redundancy, change management, and recovery planning even more important. Was the update tested? Were redundant systems affected? Why couldn't it be reversed or restored from backups? Those are ordinary questions for any network administrator, let alone the NSA.

During this period, President Trump also dismissed National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross. The timing does not establish a link to the outages, but it raises questions about whether his removal was related to the failures or to information that has not been publicly disclosed.

I raised concerns about America's infrastructure vulnerabilities twelve years ago. In my December 19, 2014, Liberty Takes Effort article, A Disappointing Press Corps, I criticized reporters for focusing on a Sony Pictures hack without asking President Obama about the broader threat. I described Sony as “reflective of a much broader vulnerability in private and government networks” and asked whether attacks on our electrical grid, communications, and financial systems might constitute an existential national-security threat.

Just months earlier, hackers had breached JPMorgan Chase, compromising information linked to 76 million households and seven million small businesses. The intrusion came after the United States imposed sanctions over Russia's actions in Ukraine and Crimea, prompting investigators to consider whether it might have been retaliation by Moscow. The FBI said it had found no evidence of such a connection, and subsequent investigations identified a criminal enterprise. Still, identifying criminals does not necessarily rule out state interests, and the lack of publicly disclosed evidence cannot resolve every intelligence question. Iran had also carried out disruptive cyberattacks against American banks earlier in the decade.

My concern goes back even further. In 1999, while serving as Intelligence Officer for the Navy's Strategic Studies Group, I led an intelligence Red Team in a war game involving a rising Asian power. As American forces deployed to the theater, I responded as the adversary by disabling the West Coast electrical grid. The lesson was simple: an opponent unable to match America's conventional military strength might instead target the infrastructure that supports our economy, military, and population.

Today, Russia, Iran, and China have reason to study these vulnerabilities. Temporary, deniable disruptions could serve as strategic warnings without triggering a conventional confrontation. I am not claiming this happened; I am arguing that the possibility warrants investigation rather than reflexive dismissal.

What troubles me is the lack of sustained, detailed questioning. If a software update caused the NSANet disruption, investigators should document the software, its authorization and testing, the personnel or contractors involved, the sequence of failures, and the corrective action taken. If criminals were responsible, investigators should pursue the evidence and prosecute where warranted. If foreign governments were involved, they should provide an appropriate account of the threat and response. These questions are becoming more urgent as our critical infrastructure ages and artificial intelligence gives potential adversaries increasingly sophisticated tools to exploit its vulnerabilities.

Classified systems require secrecy—I know that from experience. But secrecy need not prevent congressional oversight, independent technical review by cleared experts, or a meaningful public explanation.

Even if every incident was accidental, adversaries have seen how failures can disrupt essential American systems. That is hardly reassuring. Twelve years after I issued my warning, our reliance on interconnected infrastructure has only grown.

Americans deserve more than assurances from the government—they deserve answers. The press has a responsibility to demand them.

------

SHARING: Please consider sharing these blog posts via social media or via email if you find them interesting by providing a link to https://www.libertytakeseffort.com

DISTRIBUTION: If you would like to receive these blog posts in newsletter form to your email please send an email to libertytakeseffort@gmail.com. To see archived blog posts since 2014, visit www.libertytakeseffort.com

DISCLAIMER: The entire contents of this website are based solely upon the opinions and thoughts of the author unless otherwise noted. It is not considered advice for action by readers in any realm of human activity. Its purpose is to stimulate discussion on topics of interest to readers to further inform the public square. Use of any information in this site is at the sole choice and risk of the reader.